Take Control of Your Patient Flow (Part 3)

Kareo May 6th, 2013

Leave a Comment Latest by COMMENTOR NAME

by Rico Lopez, Senior Market Advisor at Kareo

Rico6

In my first blog post, Take Control of Your Patient Flow (Part 1), we looked at a host of reasons why patient flow is important and how it can impact your practice. We looked at scheduling in Part 2, and now we are going to talk about your staff schedule and the value of cross training.

To fully maximize your staff time, you must first completed the previous section on analyzing your Appointment Schedule Template. Even if you feel confident that your appointment templates are solid, you will still need to perform the previous exercise to fully understand the prospective bottlenecks of your patient flow and how to appropriately allocate resources to minimize delays. You might be surprised what you find. I have worked with clients who realized after performing this exercise that they could actually see more patients with just some minor scheduling tweaks while eliminating major bottlenecks with simple staffing adjustments.

Maximizing the Value of Your Staff

  1. Create a table to identify your existing staff, their certification/training, experience within your practice, prior experience and roles they are currently trained and can competently perform today.
    cross training
  2. Analyze your current staffing strengths and identify cross training opportunities. In the sample in Figure 1 above, I noted which role(s) each employee can cover today and I then I shaded (in blue) the 29 cross training opportunities. I am not suggesting that each employee should be cross trained in all roles for the practice – but the more flexibility you create with your staff, the easier it becomes to overcome bottlenecks in the practice.
  3. Develop a cross training strategy. While it is not realistic to cross train all your staff within a few weeks, it is a good idea to schedule cross training of your staff during ideal times for the practice. Depending on the amount of cross training needed in your practice, it could take weeks or even months to get everyone fully trained. Prioritize the cross training based on the biggest impact to your practice.
  4. Manage your staff schedule. In Figure 1 above, is it necessary to bring multiple staff members at 7:30? When does the practice really need them to come in? Are they needed more in the early morning or late in the day? What I have found in many practices is that some employers will adjust their employees work schedule to accommodate the needs of their employees without understanding the impact to the practice. Knowing your staff’s abilities (by creating the staff table above) and implementing cross training will provide you the flexibility to accommodate scheduling requests.

Identifying Bottlenecks

The last post where we created your patient flow worksheet and analyzed the downstream impact of your appointment schedule, should have given you some idea of the possible bottlenecks in your patient flow. The adjustments you made to your appointment templates as a result of your analysis will eventually provide relief.

There are other causes of delays in your practice other than those created by your appointment scheduling (we will discuss this in a future session). The key for now is recognizing when the practice begins to back up and determining the starting point of the bottleneck. Let me give you some sample scenarios that you will probably recognize:

  1. Staff are waiting for patients to be handed over from the front desk and the doctor is waiting for patients to be placed in exam rooms and lobby is full of patients.
  2. Patients charts are stacking up waiting for someone to call the patient, take them to vitals or the exam room for patient prep, half the exam rooms are empty and need to be cleaned/prepped for the next patient, provider and medical assistants are all preoccupied with patients in the other exam rooms, and the lobby is full of patients.
  3. Beginning of the day or right after the office lunch break, there is a line of patients at the front desk and there are already several patients sitting in the waiting room.
  4. Patients lining up at the check-out desk likely very frustrated and just want to leave but they still need to make follow up appointments and pick up additional paperwork.
  5. Lobby is full of patients, charts stacking up, all exam rooms are full and provider is jumping from room to room with no end in sight.

Now that you are more aware of bottlenecks and are able to quickly recognize the issue, its time to talk about what actions you can take to relieve these delays. The first four bottleneck scenarios above can all be quickly resolved by reassigning resources to the area causing the backup. In some cases, it would only take a few minutes to get the practice back on track. The fifth scenario might warrant hiring another provider, but we will talk about that in another post.

Anticipating & Planning for Challenges

There will always be events in your practice that will cause delays to your patient flow. For some practices, this is accepted as status quo and just the way the practice functions. I am here to tell you – NO IT IS NOT! There are three things you can do–Eliminate, Anticipate, and React.

  • Eliminate: If you already know about issues that causes delays in your practice, then what have you done to eliminate them? We will review this further in a future session and what you can do to identify and eliminate these issues.
  • Anticipate: No one knows your practice better than you and I am sure many of you can even predict when and where these delays will occur. The items that reoccur daily or on a very frequent basis are the ones you will need to address. Anticipating the problem will allow you to assign resources in the right location at the right time. Here is an example of one item that most practices experience. First thing in morning when multiple patients arrive at your office at the same time many practices find that they are already behind at the beginning of their day. If this happens in your practice, then anticipate the situation and assign an extra resource first thing in the morning just long enough (~30 minutes) to help overcome the initial wave of patients. Now think of other scenarios in your office where you can almost anticipate delays and implement a solution to avoid future recurrence.
  • React: Once you have addressed the anticipated delays, let us talk about the unpredictable. This is where recognition of the issue and full understanding of your staffs’ ability to cover other areas will come in handy. Don’t be afraid to move staff around throughout the day – making sure you that these adjustments will not cause a different delay for another area of the practice. Your staff will eventually begin to recognize these situations themselves and take the initiative to assist the other areas as soon as they occur without any instructions from you.

Changing the Culture

Just like any other business, one of your most important resources is your employees. Creating a working environment where their initiative and teamwork are recognized will promote an ideal scenario for any busy practice. Acknowledging employees who act on their own to back-up their struggling coworker will send a clear message to all of your employees.

Set goals and reward staff for meeting and/or exceeding them. One of the ones that my employees used to enjoy is the 5-Day Challenge. If the clinic finishes on time (you pre-define what “on time” means) for 5 days straight, then on the 6th day we have lunch brought in for everyone. Lunch is an inexpensive payment for reducing labor (or even overtime) and increasing patient satisfaction and employee satisfaction.

Watch for my next post when we will talk about overbooking and address various practice policies including no shows and patients arriving late for their appointments.

Read More

3 Easy Ways to Hire the Right People at Your Medical Practice

Kareo March 7th, 2013

Leave a Comment Latest by COMMENTOR NAME

You want to hire the right staff the first time, right? Of course you do. It takes time and money to recruit new staff and if they aren’t a good fit then before long you have to do it again. In a medical practice this can really affect your bottom line! There are things that you can do to help improve the odds of getting that qualified person who is also a good fit for your practice. Use these three simple strategies as part of your hiring process.

  1. Easiest: Test their skills. Just because a resume says someone is an expert at Excel, doesn’t mean it’s true. If running reports and managing spreadsheets is a key part of the job, test those skills. If the job is in billing, ask detailed questions about their billing skills and billing scenarios. If phone skills are critical, roleplay with the candidates and see how they would interact with people. There are many tools and resources, paid and free, that you can use to help you test candidates on specific skills.
  2. Easier: Check references! We all know references are revealing and critical, but we get busy and begin to believe we got a good sense of the person from the interview. So, we offer them the position. References are important because they have direct experience working with the person and can provide information about the candidate’s strengths, work style, and experience. To take some of the burden off of you, get the candidate involved in helping obtain the references. For instance, ask them to send to you the names, phone numbers and email addresses of 1-2 previous managers and peers. You may also ask that the candidate to send an email to their identified references with a request to contact you.
  3. Easy: Find out if the candidate’s personality is a good fit for your practice. You know the staff at your practice and what kind of person would be a good fit. If you need someone who is independent and quiet or someone who is outgoing and collaborative, ask questions such as; “Tell me about the best place you have worked and why it was the best,” or “Tell me about what tasks you enjoy the most and why.” These types of questions can help you identify the preferences and style of the candidate. Skills can be taught, experience can be obtained, but fit is unchanging. Just like shoes, when they don’t fit, they can still do the job of covering your feet, but you can’t stop thinking if the pain is worth it.

Finally, take your time. This is hard, especially when you need someone now. But remember, a bad hire today, can mean damage that lasts long after that person has left the practice. And a great hire can be a catalyst for positive impacts beyond the scope of the person’s position.

Read More

3 Easy Ways to Keep Your Medical Practice on Schedule

Kareo January 22nd, 2013

Leave a Comment Latest by COMMENTOR NAME

It may be one of the biggest challenges in a medical practice management—staying on schedule. Physicians get sidetracked with refill requests, reviewing labs, returning calls to patients. Patients take up more time than they are allotted. A registration person calls in sick and your front desk gets a little behind. There are a hundred reasons why you might get off track. But once it happens, it’s hard to get that time back. You may find that your practice is slightly behind for the rest of the day. Here are a few simple strategies that might help avoid bottlenecks or turn things around when they start to go south.

  1. Easiest: Set clear guidelines for staff about not interrupting the physician with calls or questions between appointments unless it is a true emergency.  Establish a process for the physician to receive messages and manage tasks as specific times of the day—first thing each morning, at the end of the day, perhaps a break at midday. He or she can take care of refills or return calls during those appointed times.
  2. Easier: Prioritize tasks for staff. Make sure your staff know what their top priorities are so that if they get busy they know what to let go of for the time being. Sometimes people are trying to do too much when they should just be focused on moving patients swiftly through their appointment.
  3. Easy: Do an analysis of your time management, including your scheduling process and task management. You may need to look at your days from nuts to bolts. Is your schedule inefficient? Maybe the problem is that your longest patient visits are at the wrong time of day and they are causing backups everywhere else. Perhaps you providers just aren’t managing their tasks well. For more on scheduling, see our blog post on using your schedule to increase revenue. Many practice management and electronic health record systems offer task management tools. If everyone isn’t using them to stay on top of tasks and priorities, now might be a good time to start.

In the end the most important things to remember when trying to keep things on track are making sure that everyone knows exactly what their role is, what their priorities are, and what they should do if things get busy.  Sometimes the problem is simply that people don’t know what to do next to keep things on track and they flounder.

Read More

Reduce Absenteeism at Your Medical Practice

Kareo November 29th, 2012

Leave a Comment Latest by COMMENTOR NAME

3 Easy Ways to Manage Employee Absenteeism

It is the bane of many medical practices: employees who frequently call in sick or don’t show up for work. Employee absenteeism is a huge problem for American businesses. According to the global management company Kronos International, absenteeism costs employers more than 8 percent of their payroll[1]. It also takes its toll on employee morale, not to mention productivity and workflow. While sometimes the employee may actually be sick, more often there are family illnesses or other pressures that make employees miss work. Here are some practical ways to manage employee absenteeism.

  1. Easiest: Be sure you have an absenteeism policy that states how many absences are acceptable in a defined period of time, and for what reason they are allowed. You should also address any personal reasons for which employees may be absent, such as a family member’s illness or home emergency. Delineate the consequences for not complying with the policy.  Every new employee who is hired should receive a copy of the policy and acknowledge in writing that they have received it.
  2. Easier: If absenteeism becomes an issue with one individual, address it directly. Talk with the employee to determine if ongoing adverse circumstances are affecting her ability to meet her work schedule and if so, discuss possible solutions. Of course, if calling in sick continues, be prepared to give a verbal warning and document it in the personnel file. This provides a paper trail should you need to terminate the employee.
  3. Easy:  If absenteeism occurs routinely in your office with more than one employee, there may be other issues at work—literally. According to an article published in the January 2009 “Journal of Organizational Behavior,” increased job demands and decreases in job resources are directly related to absenteeism. Consider meeting with employees, with a promise of non-retaliation, to ask if there are workflow or resource issues that prevent them from doing their jobs effectively.  Or consider bringing in a practice management expert to review your office staffing and workflow. If workplace dynamics make it difficult for employees to do their jobs, you will have a much larger problem: keeping competent qualified employees.

This is the third in an ongoing series of blog posts aimed at helping you manage the day-to-day realities of running a medical practice. Check out our last post on keeping patient information up to date, and be sure to watch Kareo’s Getting Paid blog for more in our “3 Easy Ways…” series.


[1] http://smallbusiness.chron.com/deal-employee-absenteeism-16074.html

Read More

Complimentary Webinar: Become a High Performing Primary Care Practice

Kareo October 24th, 2012

Leave a Comment Latest by COMMENTOR NAME

Tuesday, October 30, 2012
1:00 PM EDT/10:00 AM PDT

Join this panel of great thinkers and doers who will lead a discussion about how to build high performing primary care practices.

  • Dr. Sreedhar Potarazu, renowned physician, author of widely acclaimed book “Get off the Dime, The Secret to Changing Who Pays for Health Care”, Fox Business News contributor, and CEO of Vital Spring Technologies.
  • Dr. Jean-Luc Neptune, a licensed Internal Medicine physician, entrepreneur, and national leader of Health 2.0 developer challenge and Doctors 2.0 initiatives.
  • Terry Douglas, advocate for small medical practices and healthcare marketing leader at Kareo, Inc.

Are you ready for change?
On this webinar, you’ll learn:

  • Secrets that helped 7 primary care practices improve the patient experience, staff satisfaction, positive clinical quality metrics, and practice profitability.
  • How primary care physician practices could play a key role in forming a more nimble health care system.
  • Insights into a new approach for “reliable care” – where innovations, quality, and outcomes meet patient service.

Who Should Attend
Private practice owners, physicians, office managers, billing managers, billers, billing service owners and others who want to improve the performance at their primary care practice or the practices of their clients.

Register now to learn how to improve the performace of your primary care practice

Read More

Stop Denials in Their Tracks: Get Paid the First Time by Health Care Insurers, #2

Kathy McCoy, MBA August 23rd, 2012

Leave a Comment Latest by COMMENTOR NAME

Expert Betsy Nicoletti advised in this complimentary Kareo webinar that by setting up a process to measure, quantify and fix the reasons for denials, practices can significantly improve their collections and cash flow—and their bottom line.

There’s no denying it: Denials are the bane of every practice’s profit-and-loss statement. But the good news is: By setting up a process to measure, quantify and fix the reasons for denials, practices can significantly improve their collections and cash flow—and their bottom line.

That was the message during Betsy Nicoletti’s recent Kareo-sponsored webinar entitled Stop Denials in Their Tracks: Get Paid the First Time by Health Care Insurers. Betsy is a well-respected practice management and medical billing expert, as well as founder of Codapedia.com. During her webinar, she provided a blueprint for minimizing the number of denials on the claims you submit, so you can take back the dollars you are leaving in payers’ coffers. Our first blog on her webinar offered ways to track denials and the reasons for them, along with some of the more common pitfalls that trigger denials. This last blog on the webinar will recap Betsy’s strategies for getting claims clean and complete enough to pass even the most exacting claims scrutiny.

Betsy acknowledges that sometimes, it takes some detective work to determine the reason for denials. That is certainly the case with coding errors. A modifier might be added to the wrong CPT code, or modifier 59 may be added to a procedure that cannot be unbundled. Diagnostic tests may be denied because the provider failed to establish medical necessity by linking it to the correct diagnosis code. Or just as common, the test was performed more frequently than the payor allows. The solutions to coding errors are often found hidden in plain sight, in editorial comments of the CPT book. Betsy suggests you start there and read complete descriptions of codes along with the editorial comments. For complex coding issues, specialty societies can often provide information and supporting documentation and some will even field a few coding questions for free for their members.

Other errors are more easily prevented and rectified, such as misspelling the patient’s name or entering wrong demographic information; failing to verify insurance and benefits prior to the appointment; or authorization errors, such as not obtaining  pre-authorization or having the referral for services. Not filing claims on a timely basis can automatically trigger a denial, too. For all of these errors, Betsy recommends a “zero tolerance” policy that holds staff accountable for fulfilling the basics of claims submission.

Expert Betsy Nicoletti advised how to measure, manage and reduce denials in this complimentary Kareo webinar

Betsy strongly advises that medical billers fix claims before they are denied by checking clearinghouse reports daily. The reports will flag pre-adjudication errors so that they can be corrected before they are sent.  If your practice management system supports it, use technology to help you manage claims preparation and submission. Many systems can perform batch verification of eligibility or benefits, including patients’ deductible amounts, patient due amounts by benefit type, and more. Coding programs can check for bundling or diagnosis code congruence, if modifiers are allowed and if so, which ones. Take advantage of functionality such as claims estimators and electronic remittance advice and payments. To learn more about how Kareo’s powerful suite of tools helps streamlinine your medical billing and collections, visit Kareo.com

Finally, establish policies and procedures that set clear expectations for staff. They should include full registration at the time of the appointment; verification of eligibility and benefits; and authorizations prior to the appointment. Coding policies may include double-checking denials by another set of eyes before re-submitting them.

By tracking, measuring, researching and fixing the reasons for denials, practices can give themselves a much needed raise. To hear more on other practice management or medical billing issues that impact or enhance profitability, view our archived webinars to find more topics of interest to you. If you would like to be put on our notification list for upcoming informative webinars such as this one, sign up now.

Learn additional ways to improve your practice revenue: Register now for our next informational webinar, Finish Strong: Make 2012 Your Most Profitable Year! with widely respected consultant Karen Zupko.

Read More

Three Must-Do Compliance Tasks for Smaller Practices

Betsy Nicoletti, M.S., CPC August 13th, 2012

1 Comment Latest by COMMENTOR NAME

Many large groups have a dedicated compliance officer and even (gasp) compliance auditors and support staff whose only responsibility is compliance.  For smaller groups, compliance duties are shared by the manager, physician leader, and billing and coding staff, all of whom have multiple other responsibilities.  How to find time?  And if you are able to steal time from another task, where do you start?

Here are three important activities that won’t take all day, but will protect your practice.

1. Do a non E/M coding review

Print out a list of billed CPT codes by volume and revenue, and ignore E/M services.  Make a list of your top five codes billed by volume and revenue.  In all likelihood, some codes will be on both lists, so you will end up with a list of five to ten of your most frequently billed non-E/M services.

Next, review the CPT definition for the codes, read the editorial comments in the CPT book related to the services.  If you have any other up-to-date coding resources about the codes or coding instructions from Medicare on one of your payers (a National or Local Coverage Determination, for example) print that out and review it as well.

Next, pull five records billed with each of your most frequent codes.  Review the documentation.  Does the documentation describe the procedure as defined by CPT?  Does the note support the medical necessity or indication for the service? If the service is diagnostic, is the reason for the test documented in the record?  Document your findings on a spreadsheet.  Refund incorrectly paid amounts and educate your staff and providers.

2.  Check NPI billed numbers

CMS is serious about enrollment and accurate claim submission with the correct NPI. Locums, shared services, and incident to service have specific rules.   For this compliance review, trace the NPI on the claim submitted with the name in the medical record documentation.  Do they match?  Is the correct NPI being submitted in both the electronic and paper formats?  If there is a discrepancy, was it because of a shared service, incident to or locums billing?  Record your findings on a spreadsheet.  Errors in this are serious and most consultants would recommend talking to your practice attorney about discrepancies. 

3.  Avoid the wall of shame

This activity will probably take more than a day, and may require outside help.  A practice that loses 500 or more records is required to self-disclose their protected health information breach on the wall of shame.  Google HHS Wall of Shame and see for yourself.  Some of the most common breaches occur because of loss or theft of a computer that contains protected health information.  Simple solutions:

  • Encrypt data
  • Set up laptops to access medical records but not download them
  • Require frequent password changes, and no passwords on sticky notes
  • Use physical security to secure computer servers to the wall
  • Hire a security expert to do an assessment

Review your security policies frequently at staff meetings and with new staff.  Make sure no one is using a non-secured email to send or receive patient records.

Finally, schedule yourself an hour a week to just read about coding and compliance issues in physician practices.  Turn off the phone and email, and find a hideout.  Go to the library or a coffee shop.  All week long, save the articles, emails and resources that appear in your electronic and paper inbox.  During this learning hour, catch up and give yourself time to process all of the information coming your way.  If an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure, an hour of learning will save weeks of pain.

Betsy Nicoletti, M.S., CPC, is the founder of Codapedia.com, a wiki for physician reimbursement. She is a nationally known speaker and consultant, and can be reached at www.mpconsulting.org. She most recently wrote for Getting Paid on Your Nine-Step Plan to Better Practice Collections, Part I and Part II

Additional Resources

Read More

Physician Productivity Measures Should Include More Than Just RVUs

Bhagwan Satiani, MD, MBA, FACS, FACHE August 13th, 2012

1 Comment Latest by COMMENTOR NAME

Physician productivity usually refers to clinical productivity. Clinical productivity and formulas based on units of work have become the most common method of physician compensation. Indeed, the Medical Group Management Association in 2007 reported that 16% of group practices used RVU’s (or WRVU’s) to calculate physician compensation and productivity and that 34% of physicians had their compensation/productivity based on RVUs. Only three years later, MGMA reported that 35% of group practices were using RVU compensation/productivity formulas and 61% of physicians were compensated based upon RVU “production.”

A 2011 survey by Merritt Hawkins Associates, a major physician recruitment firm, showed that a salary plus a production bonus was the type of compensation formula offered to physician candidates in 74% of the physician search assignments. The survey also showed that in 50% of searches, the compensation formula was based upon RVUs (or WRVU’s). Of note is the fact that in most cases the productivity measurement was NOT based upon quality of care, patient volume, any cost effectiveness metric or revenue generated.

Besides RVUs or WRVUs, there are other ways to measure clinical productivity. Patient encounters are easily measured but do not reflect actual collections and gaming of the system is possible by encouraging short patient visits. Gross charges are also easy to calculate but do not reflect contractual adjustments or collections. Charges adjusted for insurance contracts are relatively easy to produce but are based on uncollected charges and since payer mix can vary between physicians in the same group, does not allow apples-to-apples comparison with other physicians. Net collections do reflect actual collections but may discourage physicians from providing care to uninsured or poorly insured patients. In some groups, a combination of one of the above methods may be in use that takes a middle ground.

Issues for Physician Groups

Unfortunately, a number of physicians are either not aware of the details of productivity formulas, billing procedures or the group simply does not track RVUs or WRVUs. In a recent industry survey, the percentage of physicians who say they are unaware of billing and administrative decisions is about 10%. A recent survey of Vascular Surgeons (1/3 academic) showed that only 50.3% said they or their group kept a record of RVU’s/WRVU’s.  About 70% stated some of their compensation was based on productivity, with 48% stating their productivity determined 76-100% of their compensation. More physician-owned groups reported that their compensation was based on productivity than full-time employed Vascular Surgeons.  Net collections was the most common measure of productivity (35.3%) followed by WRVU’s (24.8%).

Most groups use common benchmarks such as MGMA or AMGMA data for the productivity part of compensation formulas. A problem with tying physician compensation strictly on a per RVU or WRVU production is that when insurer payments change or groups have a bad year with a negative operating margin, the model may not be sustainable. As I have previously discussed here, RVUs as the only basis for calculating physician compensation has its drawbacks. Collections are after all still king.

For instance, for PCP’s, in addition to RVU or WRVU productivity, achieving benchmarks for management of chronic diseases like diabetes or hypertension, patient satisfaction, care coordination  and other important functions must be in the mix. This is becoming more important with the medical home concept. Participation and contribution to the group’s overall strategic plan should also be rewarded.

These new incentives may create some confusion, but physicians will begin to see the model as fair and transparent over time. In general, it is recommended that any behavioral change incentive must constitute at least 20% of the total compensation plan to get attention.

The future

Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs) are being established in every state. Large and small physician groups are now becoming part of ACOs especially in large metropolitan areas. In the last count of 221 ACOs, 70 were physician-based. In addition to Medicare ACOs, commercial ACOs are also taking off. If the goal for physicians is to be a big part in reducing the cost of healthcare in the U.S, compensation models for physicians must also be aligned with incentives for ACOs. Therefore, “productivity” must include measures other than clinical productivity. For instance, to maintain quality of care non-financial incentives must be created. These metrics can include:  patient satisfaction scores, mortality and morbidity rates. ACOs will also need physicians to lead in the operations, innovation and quality and customer service areas. One such metric is to  assign each of these activities a WRVU, which is then multiplied by the number of units on an annual basis.

For the physician side, it is clear that reimbursements are not going up. In most groups there is usually a physician who assumes an unpaid administrative role and works with the business manager or the most senior physician simply has the manager reporting to him/her. This worked well when reimbursement was good and overheads relatively low. With operating margins decreasing and reimbursement dropping, not only do physician groups need a well-educated manager, but a physician who is knowledgeable, keeps up with the changes and can look at future opportunities for growth. With Medicare ACOs, for instance, beneficiaries will have the choice to go and receive their care outside your ACO and you will have no control over costs. So, physician leaders will have to be intimately aware of costing, budgets and financial controls. Therefore, in medical groups of varying sizes, the administrative physician must be compensated or be given credit for these activities when calculating productivity.

Bhagwan Satiani, MD, MBA, FACS, FACHE, is President of Savvy-Medicine (www.savvy-medicine.com), a business education consulting organization and Professor of Clinical Surgery, Division of Vascular Diseases & Surgery, Department of Surgery, The Ohio State University College of Medicine, Columbus. He is the author of the 3-volume set “The Smarter Physician” published by MGMA and co-author of “The Coming Shortage of Surgeons: Why They Are Disappearing and What We Can Do About It.”

Additional Resources

Read More

Patient Files Disappear: Could This HIPAA Violation Happen To You?

Laurie Morgan July 11th, 2012

Leave a Comment Latest by COMMENTOR NAME

Avoid HIPAA violations with these tips from expert consultant Laurie Morgan of Capko & Company

An amazing headline from the local news here in Northern California today: “’Overwhelmed’ Clerk Brings 1500 Patient Files Home.”  The clerk apparently started bringing files home because she was falling behind in her duties – which included organizing and copying the files and creating reports for the physicians at her hospital. All of the files apparently contained test results and other medical information, and some included financial information and social security numbers. 

Are you thinking what I’m thinking? Holy HIPAA violation!  Even more alarming: this kind of thing may not even be that rare: commenters are mentioning examples of similar things happening in other medical offices across the country.  Worst of all, while the clerk in this case appears to have removed the files because she was overworked, the fact that she was able to do it suggests that someone looking to steal medical identities could have easily done the same.

Management controls and policies should have prevented something like this from happening.  What’s more, appropriate controls would have flagged the situation for attention – potentially leading to a restructuring of roles or more staff to alleviate the clerk’s disproportionate load.

How can this be avoided?

What procedures could have made a difference?  Here are a few:

Chart-handling policies:  Charts should only be removed from a medical office for very specific, HIPAA-compliant reasons (for example, when a provider will need the chart for treating the patient at the hospital).  And, it should always be clear who has control of the chart and where it is when it is removed from the office – a sign-out/sign-in system can be used for this purpose.  

Billing processes: When an external billing service is used, only needed information should be provided to the service, and the method for delivering should ensure that confidentiality is protected (and, of course, it’s essential that the service itself be HIPAA-compliant). 

Audits:  Several types of audits might have spotlighted that a clerk was removing patient information.  For example, chart audits performed to monitor billing and coding processes – a good idea to ensure your practice’s coding is ship-shape in case a payer wants an audit – would have revealed missing files. Even a weekly co-pay audit – which is a great tool to encourage staff to collect co-pays up-front – could have illuminated this issue before it got out of hand.

Staff/management communication: Weekly meetings – and some open door hours for practice managers each week – can help bring workload issues to light more productively.  If one person is consistently unable to fulfill their job duties, it’s likely the job is too big for one person, or the wrong person is doing the job.

Cross-training: If the job really was too large for one person to complete during the workday, a policy of cross-training employees could have revealed that.  Cross-training also would have prepped other staff to help out the buried employee – and is always a good idea to ensure an employee departure (or even vacation) won’t lead to backlogs and errors.

Laurie Morgan is a management consultant with Capko & Company. She specializes in marketing, management and technology for medical practices and blogs about practice management issues at www.capko.com/blog. Laurie has a BA in Economics from Brown University and an MBA from Stanford. Laurie recently wrote for Getting Paid on My Receivables Are Growing: Time for a New Billing Service?, Hidden Ways Medical Billing Shortcomings Hurt Your Practice and Fine Tune Your Hiring Process to Reduce Turnover and Build a Better Medical Billing Team, Part I and Part II.

Read More

Mitigate Potential Loss in Your Medical Practice with Controls and Visibility

Thom Schildmeyer June 13th, 2012

Leave a Comment Latest by COMMENTOR NAME

Take a look at two important ways to mitigate potential loss in your medical practice

My previous post on theft and embezzlement indicated that such loss can occur within any practice, but many practices lack the ability to quickly and easily identify the symptoms.  Let’s take a look at two important ways to mitigate potential loss in your medical practice through greater controls and visibility.

Controls

More than 10 years ago, I read an article in The Physician Advisory related to a Controls Checklist that I found valuable then—and still has value today.

The author strongly recommended using your certified public accountant (CPA) to help establish controls and cash handling processes. CPAs are experts in this area and can be a valuable resource in establishing controls and helping to monitor those controls on a monthly basis. Even if you don’t use your CPA to assist in this area, the following list of controls can help reduce the opportunities and temptation for staff to steal or embezzle.

Personnel

  • Adequately screen applicants, including reference and background checks
  • Bond your employees
  • Require vacations (prime time to uncover possible thefts)

Handling Cash

  • Make the person who takes payments responsible for balancing, but have a second person verify it
  • Write receipts for every payment received over the counter (OTC)
  • Establish separate petty cash and patient change funds and randomly verify balances
  •  Make all payments with serially numbered checks, printed by your bookkeeper , signed by the designated physician (rotating duty if multiple physician owners)
  • Don’t sign blank checks or checks lacking documentation like invoices or statements
  •  Reconcile bank statements monthly and consider having the statements sent directly to CPA (or physician home)

Accounts Receivable

  • Use and account for serially numbered encounter forms for every service
  • Occasionally track a random sample of cash receipts through your whole system, from the appointment register all the way to the counter ledger to confirm no payments are missing
  • Set up a clear policy for write-offs that
    involves either physician approval or review
  • Never allow financial records to be taken home.

Visibility

The idea that someone is actually looking is a huge deterrent to those who may have the urge to steal or embezzle. It’s how ill-informed some physician owners are on their cash, cash handling process, and responsible staff that creates the lack of visibility and deterrent. Worse, they don’t regularly review reports that may indicate there is a problem.

Reviewing month-end reports that include charges, adjustments, collections, and patient volume is very important. Many providers review these reports as a report card for physician performance. Even more important is reviewing reports related to the billing performance—for example, how much is actually collected, or what is being written off correctly and incorrectly.

Many practices encourage their providers to work hard, see more patients, and stay on time. The providers understand this and are willing to work hard. But how do you know your work is being maximized? Do you know if your biller is entering claims in a timely, accurate manner, and adding the appropriate modifier? Are they posting payments, aggressively pursuing claims not paid or partially paid, and watching payment versus allowables? And, are they sending statements to patients, following up with secondary insurance, and not taking “no” for an answer when pursuing accounts receivable (AR)?

What reports and ratios are you looking at to know for certain what is happening in the critical revenue cycle management area of your business? This is your cash flow—your livelihood—and if you don’t watch it, who will? Certainly not the person who is stealing from you, not working your claims, and is more worried about getting caught than taking care of the business.

You have to look, let staff know you are looking, and not just look at what they show you. Ask questions. Dig for details and backup data. You must have visibility to the activities into your revenue cycle management, as it is the most critical to your success.

If you are not setting up proper cash handling controls and not providing visibility, then you are providing an atmosphere that will likely result  in bad things happening. This will impact your bottom line and result in bleeding that may result in the death of your practice.

In my next post, I will cover the importance of sound revenue cycle management processes, including what reports you should be looking at and how often, versus relying on information from a staff member—perhaps someone who doesn’t have your best interest at heart.

Thom Schildmeyer is co-founder and president of Aesyntix Health, Inc. , which provides revenue cycle management and procurement cycle management (GPO) to physicians. His recent posts include:

Is Your Practice Bleeding? Medical Practice Embezzlement Is Not Uncommon

Medical Practice Theft and Embezzlement: Believe It or Not, It Can Happen to You

Read More

Welcome to Getting Paid, a weblog by Kareo offering ideas, news and opinions about medical billing and practice management with the goal of making medical billing easier and yes, getting you paid. Visit the Product Blog for more information on our products.

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Enter your email address to receive "Getting Paid" as a monthly email newsletter.

Subscribe to RSS Feed

Follow Kareo

Find Kareo on LinkedIn Find Kareo on Facebook Find Kareo on Twitter Find Kareo on YouTube Find Kareo on Flickr

Web–Based Software by Kareo

Practice Management

Simplify the daily essential tasks of your medical office from patient records, to scheduling and more.

Electronic Medical Records

Improve patient care with electronic charting, electronic prescribing and medical labs interfaces.

Medical Billing & Collections

Streamline your entire medical billing and collections process from charge entry to reporting.

Clearinghouse Services

Integrated electronic claims, electronic remittance advice and insurance eligibility services.

Analytics & Data

Store and access data with insightful reports, document management and faxing, and an integration